Chocolate rolo caramel cheesecake – #WeShouldCocoa USA entry

IMG_4664-0.jpgThis month I have been hosting #WeShouldCocoa for Choclette (ever a more appropriate name?) over at Tin & Thyme. I actually chose the theme of USA with this recipe in mind, and made it at the start of the month, but I have only just got around to writing about it.

I first saw the recipe for Rolo cheesecake bars when a friend posted it on my Facebook page, and I instantly started to dribble. Okay I know rolos are British, not American (although they are sold out there by Hershey), but cheesecakes ARE American, especially baked ones. And Graham crackers are also from the USA, and I had a packet of them in my cupboard thanks to my brother picking them up for me (from Tesco of all places), so I felt they were perfect for this #WeShouldCocoa USA entry.

IMG_4658.JPGHere’s the link to the original recipe, which I used as my inspiration for a whole cheesecake instead of to little bars. However, I’d further tweak the recipe for next time: I wasn’t a massive fan of the thick Graham Crackers base so would go with digestive biscuits next time and make it a bit thinner and more crumbly; and the glaze split a little when I chilled the cheesecake so I’d go for something different next time.

Even though I reduced the amount of sugar in the original recipe I still found it a bit too sweet for my tastes, so I’d cut down on the sugar a bit more next time as well.

But that’s not to say this version isn’t very nice … and very rich … and very large, and it may be more to your taste than the next version I try.

IMG_4669.JPGChocolate rolo caramel cheesecake – serves 12 (in brackets is my alternative proposal for the recipe)

  • For the base – 1 box (480g) of crushed Graham crackers, 225g melted butter  (or 20 crushed digestive biscuits and 50g melted butter)
  • For the cheesecake – 500g cream cheese, 2 eggs, 100g icing sugar, 60g plain flour, 3 tubes of rolos
  • For the glaze – 200g milk chocolate, 100g butter, 4tsp liquid glucose, 1 pack of rolos (or 200g dark chocolate, 200ml double cream, 1 tin caramel condensed milk, 1 pack of rolos)

I made this in a 23cm springform round tin – I lined the base with greaseproof paper. Pre-heat your oven to 180 degrees.

Firstly make the base: for this you need to crush the biscuits and mix them with melted butter (the original recipe also suggested adding sugar to the base but I thought the Graham crackers were definitely sweet enough already). Press the sandy crumbs evenly into the bottom of the base of your tin and bake for 10 minutes at 180 degrees if you are using the Graham crackers. If you are using digestives then I wouldn’t bother to bake the base as I think it is unnecessary.


While the base is baking, mix together the cheesecake filling: simply beat together the cream cheese, eggs, icing sugar and plain flour until well combined and smooth and then add the whole rolos to the mixture, distributing them evenly throughout.

Take the base out of the oven and pour the cream cheese mixture over the top, spreading it evenly over the base. Then pop the whole thing back into the oven, reduce the temperature of the oven to 170 degrees and bake the cheesecake for 30-35 minutes.

When baked the cheesecake should have a gentle wobble on it but feel set when pressed – mine took 30 minutes exactly but you might need a little bit longer.

Once cooked take the cheesecake out of the oven and allow it to cool on a cooling rack.

I recommend making the glaze (whichever version you choose) as soon as the cheesecake goes in the oven, as whichever one you make you’ll need to allow it to cool and that can take a couple of hours).


For the original glaze, melt the butter and chocolate together in a pan and add the liquid glucose. Mix the three ingredients together, making sure the chocolate doesn’t burn, and then allow it to cool slightly and thicken before spooning this over the top of the cooled cheesecake, allowing it to dribble over the sides. Decorate with whole rolos.

If you are making the alternative glaze, melt the dark chocolate into warmed double cream, stirring until well combined. As the ganache cools it will thicken. When it is so thick it barely pours (that could take a good hour or so), spread it over the top of the cheesecake. Swirl some of the caramel over the top as well to make a nice pattern and decorate with whole rolos.

Don’t forget to visit the #WeShouldCocoa page and check out some of the amazing recipes which have already been submitted, and I’ll be doing a full roundup at the end of the month so you can check them out in full.


6 Replies to “Chocolate rolo caramel cheesecake – #WeShouldCocoa USA entry”

  1. Spotted this earlier on Facebook, it looks devilishly good and perfect for Halloween!

    1. Aw thanks – I rediscovered a love of rolos when making it as well (some, er, accidentally ended up in my mouth instead of in the cream cheese mix)

  2. i bloody love rolos! will be trying this out as I love cheesecake too – perfect!

  3. Yummy!

  4. choclette says: Reply

    I had no idea you could get Graham crackers here in the UK. I’ve always been intrigued to find out how they compare to the good old digestive. What a brilliant birthday cake, gosh how much I wish someone would make me something like that. Perfect #WeShouldCocoa entry too 🙂

    1. They are really not that nice – digestives are so much nicer!

I love getting comments so please leave yours here